The data on workplace mental health is stark. Employee engagement is down across many companies. The percentage of workers who are looking for other jobs is high. Mental health issues are rampant. And many organizations don’t appear to be giving it a thought, despite the very real risks of employee misery.
Take the legal industry. A recent study by the Illinois Lawyers’ Assistance Program detailed a catalog of troubling statistics:
20% of legal professionals rated their mental health as fair or poor, citing burnout, inattention, absence, and lower quality work as business impacts.
30% had experienced vicarious trauma in the past year — lasting psychological impact from ongoing exposure at work to other people’s trauma.
28% said they had difficulty controlling their consumption of alcohol
The legal industry has long been a poster child for overwork and burnout, but it’s not an outlier. Study after study shows similarly alarming patterns across white collar workers.
The business consequences of poor employee mental health
Why does this matter? First, there are negative business consequences. Company leaders are concerned about retaining top talent, improving productivity, and reducing absenteeism. Every one of those goals requires employees who can come into work able to focus and motivated to do good work. A stressed, depressed or otherwise preoccupied workforce won’t do you any good.
Second, there are humanitarian concerns. All this misery is taking a terrible toll on people’s health and their lives. The business impact may not be direct, but it’s not hard to connect the dots between human suffering and poor outcomes.
Why therapy won’t fix workplace mental health
So what’s to be done? I’m seeing a lot of emphasis on providing more and better mental health services to employees and reducing the stigma around using those services.
Look, I’m a clinical psychologist, and I know full well the power of psychotherapy and other mental health interventions. I have seen it first-hand over decades of practice, and I’m all in favor of providing access to excellent mental health treatment.
But! That does not mean therapy is the most effective answer to the problem of workplace misery. I learned this early in my career. When I was a first-year graduate student in clinical psychology, I was part of a highly selected cohort of very motivated students. We had survived a grueling competition to be admitted to the program, and we were very excited to be studying the field we were passionate about.
Within a few months, we were utterly miserable. The faculty members were concerned that some of us were crying a lot. So they proposed group therapy.
We were livid. Everyone knew the problem wasn’t our mental health, but something terribly wrong with the academic environment. The workload was absurd. The disrespect for the students was blatant. The feedback was consistently negative. Some of the courses were poorly taught. We were struggling to cope with a really toxic environment, and sometimes it took a real toll.
In those circumstances, therapy could offer us little more than coping techniques. We needed to change the workplace, not our outlook.
The real causes of poor employee mental health
The same process is playing out in workplaces today. In the survey of lawyers, respondents mentioned these sources of stress:
Excessive workload requirement
Not being appreciated for the work they do
Feeling stuck and getting nowhere
Unfair or inadequate compensation
Feeling isolated and alone
Pressure to be in the office
Treated in a rude, intimidating, or disrespectful way
Lack of mentorship or sponsorship
Work schedule inflexibility
Lack of training for their job
My cohort and I were lucky enough to have enough clinical knowledge to know, and prove, that the problem wasn’t in us, but in the list above. Most people aren’t so lucky.
To improve mental health in the workplace, change company culture first
Most unhappy employees don’t need therapy – they need a healthy company culture. Business leaders need to focus more on ameliorating the sources of workplace misery and less on providing more treatment for their toxic consequences.
I should know. In the first 20 years of my career working as a psychologist, I saw patient after patient sick with stress from their job. I could improve their perspective, but I couldn’t change their situation. Eventually I got so frustrated I left private practice, got my MBA, and started working as a management consultant and leadership coach. Now, I work with senior leaders who can make changes that will impact hundreds or thousands of lives.
Want to improve the mental health of your employees? Figure out what’s causing their misery and make the necessary changes. If you need help, it’s what I’m here for.

